Quantcast
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 6

8th Circuit BAP Denies Discharge of Student Loan

Image may be NSFW.
Clik here to view.

The Eight Circuit Bankruptcy  Appellate Panel denied an application seeking to discharge student loans because the debtor voluntarily quit a full-time job eight months prior to filing bankruptcy.

The debtor, Erin Kemp, is a 36-year-old single mom raising a 13-year-old daughter in Arkansas.  She obtained a psychology degree in 2010 and for the past 17 years she worked for a bank earning up to $45,000 per year.  However, eight months prior to filing bankruptcy she quit her full-time bank job due to problems with depression and anxiety and took a part-time job at Lowe’s earning $13.46 per hour. She supplemented her income by performing home daycare services as well.

The bankruptcy appeals court focused on the fact that the debtor was eligible for a zero-payment Income Based Repayment (IBR) for her student loans and that her financial problems were temporary in nature.  The court focused on the following facts:

  • The debtor’s medical problems were capable of being treated with medication and until recently the debtor had successfully worked a full time job for nearly two decades.
  • Her 13-year-old daughter would attend college in a few years and not require her financial support.
  • She voluntarily quit her full time job in favor of lower-paying jobs that offered more schedule flexibility.  Thus, the debtor as asking the court to discharge her student loans due to a lifestyle change rather than from an inability to make a payment.
  • The debtor withdrew $35,000 from her retirement plan after quitting her job and paid none of it towards the student loans.
  • The debtor reported monthly income $100 from her daycare activities but such a statement was based on her taxable income and not on the daycare’s cash flow which was closer to $600/month.

The denial of a student loan discharge in this case is not surprising.  Voluntarily quitting full-time work and cashing in a retirement account eight months prior to filing bankruptcy does not rise to the standard of an undue hardship, especially when that hardship is basically self-imposed.  Yes, depression and anxiety is a real medical problem, but there was a real chance the debtor would be able to manage her condition and return to full time work in the near future.  Debtors who create self-imposed income limits are generally not viewed favorably when it comes to student loan discharge cases.

 

 


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 6

Trending Articles